States Want to Force Online Retailers to Collect Billions in Sales Tax

NATION-NOW    
          Supreme Court closely divided on changing rules for online sales tax collection        Supreme Court divided over online sales taxes

NATION-NOW Supreme Court closely divided on changing rules for online sales tax collection Supreme Court divided over online sales taxes

That practice stems from a 1992 Supreme Court decision.

Amazon, which is not involved in the Supreme Court case, collects sales taxes on direct purchases on its site but does not collect taxes for items sold on its platform by third-party venders, constituting around half of total sales.

Under a 2016 law, South Dakota requires retailers with more than $100,000 in annual sales in the state to pay a 4.5 percent tax on purchases.

At issue in the South Dakota case is a rule stemming from two, decades-old Supreme Court cases: If a business is shipping to a state where it doesn't have an office, warehouse or other physical presence, it doesn't have to collect the state's sales tax.

"Although online businesses may not have a physical presence in some states, the Web has, in many ways, brought the average American closer to most major retailers", he wrote in suggesting the days of inconsistent sales tax collection may be numbered.

A ruling for the states would put new pressure on internet retailers and marketplaces that don't always collect taxes - including Overstock.com Inc. But small businesses that sell online say the complexity and expense of collecting taxes nationwide could drive them out of business. The company now charges consumers in every state that imposes a sales tax, but only when selling products that come from its own inventory.

That sort of discrepancy is at the heart of a multibillion-dollar U.S. Supreme Court case set for argument Tuesday. "The entire nature of interstate commerce has changed", Martz said.

More news: Romaine lettuce to blame for E. coli outbreak in 11 states
More news: Gas prices hit levels not seen since 2015
More news: Uncle Jesse Is a Dad! John Stamos Welcomes a Son

And while the issue is portrayed as one of fairness for small brick-and-mortar retailers that have to compete against online retailers, experts say those small retailers could be among the ones that get hurt.

"South Dakota's choice to forego its remedy for back taxes in the event that the Court were to overrule [existing law] will not limit the retroactive application of such a ruling with respect to other state and local jurisdictions", said Wayfair's attorneys.

It's unclear how the justices might align on the question this time.

Those fighting the change say that it would impose an undue burden on small retailers who would owe not just state sales taxes but local sales taxes that many states and counties also impose. But three justices - Neil Gorsuch, Clarence Thomas and Anthony Kennedy - have suggested a willingness to rethink those decisions.

Kennedy said in 2015 that Quill had produced a "startling revenue shortfall" in many states, as well as "unfairness" to local retailers and their customers.

But Congress also could have acted any time since 1992. "The "physical presence" rule of those eras was enunciated by the Court long before virtual presence was even imaginable", added White.

"We have waited more than 25 years for Congress to act and they haven't", White said.

Recommended News

  • US Retail Sales Rose 0.6% in March

    US Retail Sales Rose 0.6% in March

    The result put sales up 4.5 per cent over the same month previous year , pointing to a trend of steady overall increases. Clothing and clothing accessory stores were up 6.1% year-over-year but down 0.8% from February seasonally adjusted.
    Hugely bought and sold Shares NXP Semiconductors NV's (NXPI)

    Hugely bought and sold Shares NXP Semiconductors NV's (NXPI)

    The stock of NXP Semiconductors N.V. (NASDAQ: NXPI ) has "Market Perform" rating given on Thursday, October 26 by Bernstein. Schwab Charles Investment Management Inc. boosted its position in shares of NXP Semiconductors by 8.8% in the 3rd quarter.
    This is how Beyonce took everyone's breath away with her Coachella performance

    This is how Beyonce took everyone's breath away with her Coachella performance

    They began their performance with their 2004 hit song Lose My Breath which was followed by Say My Name and Soldier . The audience has already started counting days but for now watch the best moments of Beyonce at Coachella .
  • Epic is considering more than 100 players for Fortnite

    Epic is considering more than 100 players for Fortnite

    If we were to put those classes into Battle Royale everyone would gravitate towards the one that has the smallest "hitbox". With a suite of cinematic settings you can now capture your most memorable moments, highlights and cinematics.
    Senior US official briefs Turkey on Syria situation

    Senior US official briefs Turkey on Syria situation

    Andrew Brunson goes on trial on charges of aiding terror groups in a case that has raised tensions between Washington and Ankara . Monday's court session will be attended by North Carolina senator Thom Tillis and US envoy for religious freedom Sam Brownback.
    Broncos release CJ Anderson

    Broncos release CJ Anderson

    With Anderson gone, only Devontae Booker and De'Angelo Henderson remain on the Denver roster as recognized running backs. Anderson to a four-year, $18 million offer sheet before the Broncos chose to match it.
  • Alleged serial killer Bruce McArthur charged in eighth death

    Alleged serial killer Bruce McArthur charged in eighth death

    Police have said they plan to search at least 70 more properties where they believe McArthur, a self-employed landscaper, worked. After receiving assistance from an unnamed global government agency, Idsinga said police were able to identify the victim.
    John Oliver offers Russel Crowe's jockstrap to Anchorage Blockbuster

    John Oliver offers Russel Crowe's jockstrap to Anchorage Blockbuster

    The premium-TV talk show purchased additional killer (or "pointless", in Oliver's words) Crowe memorabilia from the actor's divorce auction - and the HBO host wants to donate it all to the last remaining Blockbuster Video store in Anchorage, Alaska.

    Samsung Galaxy J2 Pro Can Not Access Internet Purposely

    The patent might also be for a new type of screen protection, probably some sort of in-house scratch-resistant glass. However, it is reassuring knowing that you have more power since 2GB of RAM for a smartphone seems to be important.
  • Bank of America's profit rises 34% on higher interest rates, loan growth

    Bank of America's profit rises 34% on higher interest rates, loan growth

    With $37 highest and $24.0 lowest [Target] Bank of America has $33.63 average [Target] or 12.85% above the current ($29.8) price. Therefore 67% are positive. 17 are the (NYSE: BAC)'s analyst reports since October 31, 2017 according to StockzIntelligence Inc.
    United Kingdom  joins Syria air strikes in response to chemical attack

    United Kingdom joins Syria air strikes in response to chemical attack

    He said: "The goal of our actions tonight is to establish a strong deterrent against the production, spread, and use of chemical weapons".
    7 inmates dead, 17 hurt in SC  prison fight

    7 inmates dead, 17 hurt in SC prison fight

    Autopsies should confirm their causes of death, and their names won't be released until their families are notified, Logan said. Several emergency crews responded to the Lee Correctional Institution in Bishopville where seven inmates were killed.

We are pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news.
Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper.
Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.