Supreme Court decides case on purging voter registration rolls

Supreme Court decides case on purging voter registration rolls

Supreme Court decides case on purging voter registration rolls

The court's conservative majority held that this practice does not violate federal voting rights laws.

Under the disputed procedure, OH mails notices to people who haven't voted in two years, asking them to confirm that they still live at that address.

Unlike many voting cases that come before the court, Monday's case centered not on grand constitutional principles but on interpreting seemingly contradictory directives of federal law.

As the New York Times explains, federal law forbids removing people from registration rolls because of a failure to vote, but it gives state officials leeway to drop voters who they think have moved. "Registrants who have not responded to a notice and who have not voted in 2 consecutive general elections for Federal office shall be removed from the official list of eligible voters", according to the NVRA, "except that no registrant may be removed exclusively by reason of a failure to vote".

OH state officials argued that the practice is an attempt to keep the list of registered voters up to date, removing people, for example, who have moved to another state.

In a 5-to-4 opinion that pitted the conservative majority against the more liberal justices, the high court upheld Ohio's "use it or lose it" policy of cleaning up its voter rolls, known as the supplemental process.

OH has sent more than 3 million notices of address confirmation since 2011, when Husted became Secretary of State. A handful of other states also use voters' inactivity to trigger a process that could lead to their removal from the voting rolls.

Supreme Court decides case on purging voter registration rolls

Civil rights groups said the court should be focused on making it easier for people to vote, not allowing states to put up roadblocks to casting ballots.

In a 5-4 decision, the court ruled OH could continue to remove individuals from voter rolls if they had not voted in two federal elections and have not responded to a confirmation notice or update their registration. According to briefs in the case, Harmon "expressed his dissatisfaction with the candidates by exercising his right not to vote".

Steve Vladeck, CNN Supreme Court analyst and professor at the University of Texas School of Law, said other states could follow Ohio's lead.

Justice Stephen Breyer, writing in dissent, said the 1993 law prohibits removing someone from the voting rolls "by reason of the person's failure to vote". Alito said OH skirts that prohibition by sending voters the postcard, to which they can respond before their registrations are canceled. "And in doing this, OH simply follows federal law". "It does not", Justice Alito wrote. When he showed up at the polls in 2015 he was told his registration had been canceled.

So it might be off to the races for a new round of voter suppression, all justified by a yet-to-be-documented risk of voter fraud, and a new burden for beleaguered voting-rights activists who must now focus on educating vulnerable communities on how to avoid or mitigate purges. The majority concluded that the practice under challenge - which cancels the registration of voters who do not go to the polls and who don't respond to a notice - does not violate the National Voter Registration Act of 1993 (NVRA) and the Help America Vote Act.

After registered voters miss one federal general election, they receive a mailed notification acting to confirm their address.

No other Justice joined Thomas' opinion, perhaps because the question it raised was not necessary to uphold Ohio's rule. If they do not respond and do not vote over the following four years, they are purged. "It does not." The court's four more liberal justices dissented.

More news: Congress Couldn't Kill Obamacare. But Trump Is Still Trying
More news: Meghan and Harry to tour Australia and New Zealand
More news: Vettel takes 50th win and F1 championship lead in Canada

Recommended News

  • Spain to offer

    Spain to offer "safe port" for ‘Aquarius’ migrant rescue ship in Valencia

    Among those on board are 400 migrants rescued by the Italian navy and merchant vessels before being transferred to the Aquarius . Dalli accused the Italian government of breaching global maritime laws by refusing to allow the Aquarius to berth in its ports.
    How to have tough conversations about mental health

    How to have tough conversations about mental health

    Alejo encourages anyone with thoughts of suicide or anyone needing help to reach out to pillar or other organizations. A frank approach can let the person know "you're not afraid" of the subject and you care enough to ask, she said.
    Lyon say Nabil Fekir transfer negotiations with Liverpool have ended

    Lyon say Nabil Fekir transfer negotiations with Liverpool have ended

    He came on in the second half of that game, which was at Lyon's home ground, to a great reception from the home fans. France forward Nabil Fekir's move from Lyon to Champions League runner-up Liverpool fell through on Saturday.
  • Fox News host sorry for calling Trump, Kim 'two dictators'

    Fox News host sorry for calling Trump, Kim 'two dictators'

    As the video feed featured Trump exiting Air Force One, Huntsman stated that Trump's meeting with Kim on Tuesday is "history". Scaramucci brushed right past Huntsman's apparent gaffe and instead offered praise for Trump's foreign policy strategy.

    Microsoft Reveals Gears of War 5 And Two Side Games

    Gears Tactics is now in pre-alpha and looks like a Gears of War take on the turn-based strategy gameplay of the recent XCOM games. Yes, the highly popular and collectible Funko Pop toy franchise is branching out into games.
    'Just incredible' as Nadal wins 11th French Open despite late injury scare

    'Just incredible' as Nadal wins 11th French Open despite late injury scare

    He also let four match points go at 5-2 but he would not be denied as Thiem went long with a backhand on the fifth. Across the other slow-medium clay venues - Monte Carlo, Barcelona and here - Nadal has utterly schooled Thiem.
  • BT boss Gavin Patterson to step down

    BT boss Gavin Patterson to step down

    Premier League soccer TV rights and the acquisition of British wireless venture EE from Deutsche Telekom AG and Orange SA. At the height of Patterson's tenure, BT stock reached a 15-year peak shortly after his record bet on U.K.
    Tyson Fury Kisses His Opponent On Return To The Ring

    Tyson Fury Kisses His Opponent On Return To The Ring

    Fury could now face former WBC world cruiserweight champion Tony Bellew as he gears up towards a heavyweight clash. The objective is to get him ready to fight for the world title as soon as possible.
    John Beilein withdraws from Pistons' head coaching search

    John Beilein withdraws from Pistons' head coaching search

    He has guided the Wolverines to two Big Ten titles, eight NCAA tournament appearances and two national runner-up finishes. He had a meeting and an interview with Pistons officials last week as Detroit searches for their new head coach.
  • Pep Guardiola: I will never coach Barcelona again

    Pep Guardiola: I will never coach Barcelona again

    In Barca, some have also asked the question. "We were together two years and it is only now when he says it. Maybe we Africans are not always treated by some in the same way as others.

    Long-Awaited Kingdom Hearts III Release Date Finally Announced

    Confirmed worlds include Big Hero 6 , Toy Story , Tangled , Monsters, Inc ., and the returning Olympus Coliseum world. Nomura said regarding the release date, "I'm sorry that we're asking for a little more time than initially planned".
    Verizon CEO McAdam retiring, Vestberg named successor

    Verizon CEO McAdam retiring, Vestberg named successor

    Its Oath subsidiary reaches about one billion people around the world with a dynamic house of media and technology brands. McAdam is retiring this year, and once he does retire, he will transition into the non-executive chairman of the company.

We are pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news.
Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper.
Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.