World’s First Genetically Modified Babies Created, Chinese Scientists Claim

Jiankui He                  YouTube  The He Lab

Jiankui He YouTube The He Lab

Without commenting directly on He's controversially claimed work, Baltimore said: "It is unfortunate that his work has not yet been peer-reviewed, and so there is not an independent analysis offered by experts".

A BBC article describes this news as "dubious", but there's reason to believe the claims could be true. He explained how his team used CRISPR to edit out a gene, CCR5, to remove the receptors that bind with HIV, effectively preventing the disease from being transmitted.

Some in the science community said it is human experimentation. Immediately after the 2016 experiment, the scientists destroyed the embryos, saying more research will be required before modified embryos can be implanted in a mother's womb. It would be a significant step, and it's raised widespread ethical concerns among researchers. Some have called He's work illegal, but while human cloning is illegal in China, gene editing isn't. Editing particular sequences can change those messages, and CRISPR/Cas9 is the tool that can do that.

While AP did not specify what happened with the unused embryos, bioethicist Joy Riley, executive director of the Tennessee Center for Bioethics & Culture, told BP they presumably were destroyed or frozen, both morally problematic outcomes. Research suggests it also increases a person's chance of dying from influenza.

Doudna also cited the global consensus reached in 2015.

According to the South China Morning Post, the letter was published on social media on late Monday and was signed by scientists at some of China's leading research universities, such as Peking University and Tsinghua, as well as overseas institutions, including Stanford in the United States and Singapore's Agency for Science, Technology and Research. "Performing gene surgery is only permissible when the risks of the procedure are outweighed by a serious medical need". One of these couples recently gave birth to a set of twins. Without such documentation, it's impossible to verify whether the girls indeed showed successful CRISPR editing or not. He said there appeared to be no harm caused to other genes. "Who doesn't want to be smarter, live longer, be stronger and healthier?" one post said. Many scientists working in genetics say they believe such experimentation is unsafe.

It's not the usual way that reputable scientists announce their breakthroughs to the world, but on Monday, Jiankui He released a video proclaiming that he had produced the world's first human babies whose genomes were edited using the powerful technique called CRISPR.

Musunuru is a gene editing expert and editor of a genetics journal.

More news: Complaint against 2.0: Mobile-phone operators want film certification revoked
More news: Sydney weather: storm and flooding cause traffic chaos for commuters
More news: Domestic Violence Is The Most Common Killer Of Women Around The World

He's employer, Southern University of Science and Technology, said in a statement that it was not informed about He's human gene-editing work and has opened an investigation.

On consent forms that the parents were asked to sign, He called his work "AIDS vaccine development", the AP reported, so it is not clear if the parents of the girls understood what he planned to do.

A notice from Shenzhen's medical ethics authority said that all medical organisations must establish an ethics review committee before undertaking biomedical research concerning humans, and the ethics board of the hospital involved had not completed its registration as required.

He received his PhD at Rice University in Houston, Texas, and worked as a postdoctoral research fellow in Stephen Quake lab at Stanford University according to the site. We can take comfort in the widespread condemnation of He by his own university, colleagues, and academics in the field worldwide.

Nobel laureate David Baltimore said the work would "be considered irresponsible" because it did not meet criteria many scientists agreed on several years ago before gene editing could be considered.

A fascinating aspect of this alarming story is that He was not trying to cure a genetic disease. A particular mutation in that CCR5 gene is thought to confer some resistance to HIV by making it harder for that virus to enter cells.

Unfortunately, the brazen recklessness exhibited by He will now place a dark taint on that futuristic prospect. The news spread like wildfire and garnered huge criticism from scientists for meddling with embryos using technology.

Recommended News

  • Hyde-Smith wins Senate runoff

    Hyde-Smith wins Senate runoff

    The GOP grew its majority in the Senate by two seats in this year's midterm elections even as Democrats took control of the House. Those turned out to be a form of protest against Hyde-Smith, thought that wasn't clear when the story was first reported .
    Alan Dershowitz says Mueller report will be ‘devastating’ to President Trump

    Alan Dershowitz says Mueller report will be ‘devastating’ to President Trump

    Special counsel Robert Mueller would be well advised to lay out the case and allow Congress to draw its own conclusions, he said. When the report will be made public is still anybody's guess. "The rebuttal will put a different spin on it.
    Scientist's claim of gene-edited babies creates uproar

    Scientist's claim of gene-edited babies creates uproar

    He refused to identify the parents or their location, and no scientific journal has independently verified his claims . Gene editing technology is revolutionising biology - and now twin human baby girls may be a living part of this story.
  • Artemis Fowl movie drops first fairy-fighting trailer

    Artemis Fowl movie drops first fairy-fighting trailer

    The costume designer is Sammy Sheldon Differ ( Assassin's Creed ), and the film will be edited by Martin Walsh ( Wonder Woman ). For the uninitiated, Artemis Fowl is a children's book series about a criminal mastermind child prodigy.
    Forest Service releases video of gender reveal explosion that caused wildfire

    Forest Service releases video of gender reveal explosion that caused wildfire

    The shot shows the words "BOY" and "GIRL" written across a target that's surrounded by tall grass. He will face five years' probation. "I feel absolutely frightful about it".
    Andaman and Nicobar Police recce North Sentinel island, sight tribals

    Andaman and Nicobar Police recce North Sentinel island, sight tribals

    Outsiders are banned from even approaching the island so as to protect the people who live there, and their way of life. The population of North Sentinel Island, which is about the size of Manhattan, is estimated to be 40-125 people.
  • City of Genoa Offers to Host Copa Libertadores Final

    City of Genoa Offers to Host Copa Libertadores Final

    Boca Juniors President Daniel Angelici, however, said he will appeal the decision at the Court of Arbitration for Sport "if needed".
    North Carolina fires coach Larry Fedora

    North Carolina fires coach Larry Fedora

    But Brown? Yeah, the 67-year-old national title victor at Texas, retired since 2013, is a name floating around boosters at UNC. As you see above, former Texas Tech head coach Kliff Kingsbury is a name mentioned on the staff, which is pretty intriguing.
    Leonard responds to Popovich’s claim he wasn’t a leader

    Leonard responds to Popovich’s claim he wasn’t a leader

    It's worth noting that Popovich had previously praised Leonard's leadership, saying he was a quiet presence who led by example. Popovich recently grabbed headlines when he claimed that Leonard wasn't a leader during his time with the San Antonio Spurs .
  • Cavs Inquired About Markelle Fultz

    Several teams reportedly had expressed an interest in McConnell at the beginning of the season, including the Phoenix Suns. Markelle Fultz is meeting with multiple shoulder specialists in NY this week to get an opinion about his situation.
    Manafort met with Julian Assange ahead of 2016 leaks

    Manafort met with Julian Assange ahead of 2016 leaks

    Manafort, 69, denies involvement in the hack and says the claim is "100% false". "It is unclear why Manafort wanted to see Assange and what was discussed".
    Priyanka Chopra’s pre-wedding dinner: Who wore what

    Priyanka Chopra’s pre-wedding dinner: Who wore what

    Our desi girl will soon be the bride of Nick Jonas and they will take the wedding vows at the Umaid Bhawan Palace in Jodhpur. We have rooms till November 28 and again starting from December 4.

We are pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news.
Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper.
Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.